Adrian Chiles 

Instant gratification is ruining our lives – and for me it started with my CD player’s shuffle button

Not even a compelling TV drama can stop me from staring at my phone. But this urge started 40 years ago, with what was at first presented as a useful feature, writes Adrian Chiles
  
  

A person pressing their finger on the pause button of a CD player
‘The whole natural order of things shifted.’ Photograph: Sophonnawit Inkaew/Getty Images

I blame the shuffle button. That’s what started me on the long road to a thoroughly scattered mind – generally unable to focus on anything for more than a few minutes or even seconds. I was always a bit like this, hence an ADHD diagnosis in later life. But back in the day I still managed to read a lot of books, watch long films and listen to whole records at one sitting. Now? Not so much. Actually, hardly ever.

Even something on television that I’m really engaged in – a drama or a football match – can hold me for only a few minutes before I find myself scrolling on my phone looking for I know not what. I don’t know whether it’s because I’m drawn to the small phone screen, or rather that I find absorption with whatever I’m watching on the big flatscreen just too much to bear.

I saw this process brilliantly summarised in a tweet by an American writer, Delia Cai, in which she berated herself for “another day of staring at the big screen while scrolling through my little screen so as to reward myself for staring at the medium screen all week”. That nails it. TV screen, phone screen, computer screen. Each somehow too compelling for us to focus on any one of them at the expense of the others. Ironically, of course, I came across this tweet while pawing away at my own small screen while (not) watching my bigger screen.

This has got to stop. It’s mad. And I trace the madness back to the shuffle button on my first CD player. This was 1989, towards the end of my student days. A record player, and many records, had cumbersomely accompanied me to the various dorms, flats and houses I’d called home. Now the era of the CD player had dawned and I wanted in.

Off I went to one of the dozens of hi-fi shops then plying their trade on London’s Tottenham Court Road. The bloke talked me through my options. Pointing at a shuffle button, he said: “Shuffling the tracks on your favourite album can breathe new life into it.” I remember him saying this very clearly.

On the way home I bought two CDs – an album I didn’t own, and an album I’d listened to, round and round on my turntable, a thousand times. I got back to my room, plugged things in, and lay on my bed listening to Shooting Rubber Bands at the Stars by Edie Brickell and New Bohemians. (My goodness, what a lot of words there are in that album and artist name. It’s a wonder I’ve managed to write them all down without losing focus.) I listened to it from beginning to end and quite enjoyed it.

Then I put on Dylan’s Blood on the Tracks and tried breathing new life into it by pressing that shuffle button. I didn’t much enjoy the experience. Disorientating. It felt like something had changed beyond the mere order of the tracks – the whole natural order of things perhaps. Something had shifted.

For the first 22 years of my life, listening to music had entailed dropping a needle on a record and listening to the whole of that side of the record. Yes, every now and again I’d stand up, go to the record player, lift the needle and drop it back down elsewhere on the vinyl, to listen to something again or even miss something out. But this was rare, if only because it was too much bother. So you’d listen to the whole thing.

Your enjoyment of your favourite track would even be enhanced for it having been preceded by a song you weren’t so keen on. Spared as we were in those innocent days from the dark forces of instant gratification, you’d stick with the track, knowing something better was coming. If You See Her, Say Hello, on side two of Blood on the Tracks, was so much better if you’d just put yourself through nine minutes of Lily, Rosemary and the Jack of Hearts, the track that preceded it. Sorry, Bob: not for me, that one.

The trouble with the shuffle button was that it was then but a short step to the skip button, which marked the end of music listening as we knew it, or at least as I knew it. Didn’t like a track? Just skip it. I’m not sure I’ve listened to Lily, Rosemary or indeed the Jack of Hearts since. But something more than a track had been lost. In fact, with Edie Brickell, all but one track on the album was lost. I liked Circle, track six, so before long it was the only track on the album that I troubled myself to enjoy. Skip, skip, skip, skip, skip, listen, end. Gratification: instant. Music-listening experience: diminished. Ability to concentrate: impaired.

Nearly four decades on, the skip button on a CD player feels archaic indeed. In fact, what’s a CD player? Just as the skip button made needle-lifting feel like a faff, music streaming on your phone makes pressing a CD’s skip button feel like hard labour. Who listens to whole albums now?

I asked this question on my radio show on the day the Ivor Novello award for best album was made. I wasn’t long looking for an answer before I realised I might be asking the wrong question: it’s less about who listens to a whole album, than who manages to get to the end of a whole song.

Spotify keeps tabs on who’s listening to what. And, encouragingly, for its end-of-year Wrapped feature, 2025 saw the introduction of a Top Albums metric. Great. But fascinatingly, depressingly, in Spotify’s words: “Albums make the list when you’ve listened to at least 70% of an album’s tracks, whether from the album page, within playlists, or any other place on Spotify.” So in other words, you only need ever (and then not all at once) to have listened to less than three-quarters of any given album. What’s that all about?

As for individual songs, as far as I can see Spotify keeps its data close to its chest, but a peer-reviewed study from 2020 has it that a quarter of songs are skipped within five seconds, and only around half are listened to all the way through.

Skip music, skip words, skip pictures, skip films, skip anything that dares to demand a moment of your attention. We’re skipping our way to species oblivion.

• Adrian Chiles is a broadcaster, writer and Guardian columnist

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*