Nancy Groves and Sian Cain 

Tim Minchin Q&A – as it happened

Tim Minchin can turn his hand to most things, including your questions - read his answers to readers' queries
  
  

Tim Minchin
Closet romantic … Tim Minchin Photograph: PR

Thank you everyone: that's the end of Tim's Q&A!

While we would love to keep him here in the Guardian offices forever, Tim has to head off.

User avatar for TimMinchin1 Guardian contributor

Well, that was fun. I've got to run. Thanks for all your questions.

Thank you to everyone for your questions. We're very grateful to Tim, for coming in and doing his best to answer them. We hope you enjoyed it!

Updated

harriHarris asks what we've all wondered at least once:

What eyeliner do you wear?

User avatar for TimMinchin1 Guardian contributor

Mac. I said I'd never mention it unless people ask me directly. And they give me lots of it for free.

Updated

IreneLavington says:

Hi. There's increasing interest in Dahl as we get towards the centenary of his birth, with plans for films of BFG and Matilda The Musical (yippee!) already announced. But what life advice does Dahl's work hold for the young person, if any, and is it still valid in today's often tree-less world?

User avatar for TimMinchin1 Guardian contributor

I'll digress from this one a bit. Forgive me. I've been thinking a lot recently about the messages my work puts out. Obviously the wider your audience gets, the more you have a responsibility to put out positive stuff (with great power comes great responsibility, bla bla bla). And I've become increasingly interested in fourth wave feminism for two reasons: firstly, I'm intrigued by the productive and self-destructive way it manifests itself on the internet; secondly: I have a daughter and so I'm interested in what society feeds her.

So, I've been revisiting whether – five years after it was written – Matilda holds up as a text to be proud of. Especially in terms of what it says about women and girls.

Most of the kids in my daughter's school year (she's seven) are understandably obsessed with Frozen! I vaguely know Bobby and Kristen who wrote the songs and they are awesome and I really enjoyed the movie. However, despite its best efforts it doesn't quite manage to undo the princess stereotype which Disney has made so pervasive for 50 years plus. Not all texts have to right the wrongs of the past, of course. And Disney has a right to provide Disney-style stuff.

But it's an odd message, isn't it? It feels like a sort of male ideal feminism: where women are sassy and gutsy and not easily won over. And yet, and yet ... when Let It Go happens the dress gets shorter and the boobs get bigger. And the bum comes out. And suddenly we're back in sexualised Tinkerbell-land.

Oddly, Dahl who supposed to be a little old school created in Matilda an amazing role model for girls. And we, I think, translated that faithfully onto stage. So I'm proud. Still.

Satan6 asks:

Are you happy? Are you happy with what you have, and where you are in life at the moment? Just... are you happy?

User avatar for TimMinchin1 Guardian contributor

I'm very happy. But I was before too. It's a slightly different kind of happy because it involves a house or two and a pool ... things to which I never really aspired and certainly didn't expect. However, in the 10 years that I've gone from having barely a pot to piss in to having une piscine (that shit's why I get the big bucks) I have also acquired two children which didn't cost me anything. So I suppose the nature of my happiness would have changed anyway.

I deal with a lot more stress and many people rely on me now. However I'm built pretty well for stress so I mostly feel perfectly cope-ious.

I always believed – and perhaps because of what happened in my career now have empirical data – that happiness is more to do with how you're wired than how you're treated when you were wee; than the stuff you get. Total cliche. But like all good cliches, true and French.

purpleowl asks:

I find some of your work incredibly funny but why do you hate us Christians so much?

I can understand why you hate some of the actions carried out by Christians who act inappropriately & institutionalised anything causes major problems but the majority of Christians in the UK are peaceful & compassionate people whose beliefs are being constantly belittled by you and whilst I enjoy a rigorous intellectual debate some of the things you say are vitriolic rather than intelligent and it's hurtful that this is the approach you take.

User avatar for TimMinchin1 Guardian contributor

Of course I don't hate Christians. In fact, I love many individual Christians. If any of my songs seem personally vitriolic, I'd need to know which lyrics because I'm generally at pains to ensure the target is the damaging belief not the personal who holds it. I know that sounds like the ridiculous distinction between "the sinner and the sin" trotted out by homophobic Christians!

I understand that it would feel personally offensive to have your beliefs laughed at but my belief is that faith – the idea of faith – is on the whole damaging. As a result it is the target of my satire. However, in my life, I am a humanist which means my main concern is neither the absence of belief nor a particular belief system should be treated differently in the eyes of the law, so long as the belief system doesn't harm others. I know most Christians in this country are liberal and loving, but that's because most humans are. And too often the doctrine of Christianity is used to justify the not-liberal and loving bits.

I could go on about this forever obviously. But I hope you believe me that I genuinely don't hate anybody.

cehack asks:

What do you think of the new pope?

User avatar for TimMinchin1 Guardian contributor

He seems a hell of a lot better and I have no doubt he has a good heart. He suffers slightly from a belief that Jesus was magic.

recesnap asks:

How's Groundhog Day going? Loved the song you performed from it at Hyde Park!

User avatar for TimMinchin1 Guardian contributor

We've finished the first workshop on Saturday in London. It's looking exciting, but it's so hard to know how good it's going to be. I'm incredibly impatient to see it on its feet. I'm glad you like Seeing You. I love playing it and people seem to react really strongly to it. I hasten to add, not all the songs are so emotional! There's heaps of comedy and a predictable tendency towards too many lyrics : )

Nell Webb asks:

Hi Tim. Will the rock and roll cane toad you are going to play in 'Larrikins' be a nerd, i.e., play piano or guitar?

User avatar for TimMinchin1 Guardian contributor

No. Our animal world is pure animal ie. they won't wear clothes or use tools. Andrew is simply the Freddie Mercury of cane toads. Actually, that has implications. Maybe the Pavarotti. Or the Celine Dion. Or the Atticus Fetch.

heatburg wants to know:

(1) You keep saying you're retired from comedy. Are you really seriously actually? Officially?

(2) Now that you're based in LA, is there any chance of an American tour? Even a short one?

User avatar for TimMinchin1 Guardian contributor

No I haven't retired.

It's a weird thing, I'm still known as a comedian and yet in 20 years of working in the arts, I've done a total of five years of comedy. I absolutely love performing and get a particular kick out of comedy, so I definitely intend to do more. Trouble is, great opportunities keep coming up and it's easy to keep pushing my own stuff down the list. Good problem to have but a problem nonetheless.

Rachel Jackson asks:

I want one of your songs to play at my funeral. Which one do you think makes the best dirge song? (Or if you want to write a new song about my body getting burned up into ashes or digested by worms or something, that would work, too.) Thanks in advance for all the gasps I'll get from old-timey attendees.

User avatar for TimMinchin1 Guardian contributor

I like the idea of a song about my (or your) rotting corpse. I'll put it on the list.

I've written a song for Groundhog Day about the inevitability of death that would be perfect. It wont' be in the public domain for 18 months. Can you hold on?

HerbGuardian asks:

Any relation to Louise Minchin, the lady on BBC breakfast news?

User avatar for TimMinchin1 Guardian contributor

I am related to her, but I'm also related to bark.

User avatar for TimMinchin1 Guardian contributor

(I just typed Bach – signed Nancy)

Updated

crayon711 has another:

If you were a time traveler, who would you like to meet and greet with except JC?

User avatar for TimMinchin1 Guardian contributor

Vonnegut (pathologically laid-back genius); Joan of Arc (delusional uber-leader); Voltaire (if I can time-travel I can be a polglot, surely?); and my great-grandchildren. This goes in both directions, ya?

User avatar for TimMinchin1 Guardian contributor

Mark Twain should be on the top of that list.

crayon711 asks a very Australia-oriented question (about an AFL team):

Any plan on writing a club song for the Dockers?

User avatar for TimMinchin1 Guardian contributor

I'd love to but I'm one of the few who actually adore the existing one.

Heave ho.

Updated

RockNRollNerd has a few:

Ok so firstly, generic fan question- could you pick a favourite song (either personally or to perform) that you have written for your shows and then is there any that you slightly dread performing because you have made it hard work for yourself- complicated lyrics etc? ;)

Secondly, what have been your top 'f**k yeah that's brilliant' moments in songwriting? I imagine the point of realisation that the word GINGER is spelled with a couple of G's, an R and an E, an I and an N was quite the way up there ;)

Do you think you would ever consider writing an album of more serious songs?- I know you have said before that you tried and it always ended up in comedy because you never took yourself too seriously but Not Perfect, White Wine In The Sun, Beauty, Feel Like Going Home, Understand It, My House, When I Grow Up and the 'new one'(Seeing You For The First Time?), from Groundhog Day I believe, are all SO beautiful and wistful and give me this sort of bittersweet feeling that makes me want to smile and cry simultaneously ;)

Have you ever worried about audience reaction when performing a song for the first time?

User avatar for TimMinchin1 Guardian contributor

Okay some short answers. I love most of all playing the songs I get to rock out on – getting laughs is a huge buzz but it diminishes the more you do the joke, whereas playing music is always a joy. So Dark Side and Cheese never get old for me, especially when I'm playing with amazing musos as I was on Thursday night.

I only dread complicated songs when I haven't done enough gigs.

Yes the discovery of the ginger anagram was a strange eureka moment.

So yes I will write a serious album one day, one day, one day. Tomorrow and tomorrow.

Regarding worrying audience reactions: having a tense audience that you know you are about to relieve (guffaw) is the best feeling a comedian can have.

CazGoodwoman asks:

Please tell us what you whispered to the bear

User avatar for TimMinchin1 Guardian contributor

I tell them to ignore me regardless of what I do. And then to dance when I tell them to dance. I also tell them that the more they throw themselves into the more fun they'll have and if they don't dance, they'll look like fucking tools. Not a bad rule for life that.

Tim having a read of your questions

Updated

Mary Hosbrough asks:

Why does "When I Grow Up" make us cry?

User avatar for TimMinchin1 Guardian contributor

It makes us cry because many or maybe all of us carry around (perhaps subconsciously) a sense that grown-up us has let child us down.

It was the first song I wrote for Matilda because I was trying to find my way into the piece ... to find a tone that would inform the whole. I had a young daughter and Sarah was six months pregnant when I started writing. One of the most visceral experiences of having your own kids is a sort of heartbreaking innocence they display. Which in turn reminds you that you were once that naive and that memory kind of hurts, because now you are all scarred up and cynical (even if you are a romantic like me). Perhaps the song manages to capture a bit of the romance and a bit of the scar. Or something. Plus they are on swings. What's not to cry at?

Will Papa Lazarou Spence asks:

How and when did you first realise that you wanted to perform for a living?

User avatar for TimMinchin1 Guardian contributor

There was no moment of realisation but I suppose the idea that it was possible came to me in my teens. But unlike kids that you see on American idol who seem to always to have the audacity to have dreamed of being a massive star from the age of five, I never thought beyond the dream of getting paid to sit at a piano and play songs in a bar. I just wasn't brought up to think that someone like me could create on a global level. My aspirations grew bigger very gradually and were always pegged to what I had already done. I often talk about the danger of long term goals and big dreams. And the reason is that I've been very well served by focusing on working hard at short term goals without regard for audience eyes or potential financial gain. Easy for me to say now of course, as I have big audiences and make a living.

aburt06 asks the important question:

West Coast or Fremantle?

User avatar for TimMinchin1 Guardian contributor

suddenlygiraffe asks:

How does writing a song from a source material, as with Matilda and now Groundhog Day, compare to writing songs inspired by only your own thoughts? What is different in the writing process? Is it more challenging or does having a pre-set story/theme make it easier?

User avatar for TimMinchin1 Guardian contributor

Obviously writing songs for someone else's story is easier in that you don't have to come up with an idea out of nowhere. Having said that, it's a greater puzzle to try and work out what a character can sing that allows us to have an insight into the character and into ourselves. You have an obligation not only to serve the story and the character development but also to say something broader about the way the world is or the human condition. Whereas with my own songs, my primary objective is satire and laughter so you're less restricted . But sometimes the best inspiration comes from strong parameters. At least you're never staring at a totally blank page when you're working on a theatre piece.

User avatar for TimMinchin1 Guardian contributor

Hi this is Tim typing through the hand of my new friend Nancy. I mention this because my tone might seem weird (I write differently from how I talk). And Nancy can't spel.

User avatar for siancain Guardian contributor

Hello all! Tim is here, but we're running a bit late - he will start answering questions in five minutes. Thank you for your patience!

Tim Minchin is here, ready to answer your questions

Comedian, songwriter and Ginger-rights campaigner Tim Minchin is in the Guardian offices – and for the next hour he will be answering your questions. So take a took below the line and add yours if it's not already been asked.

Post your questions for Tim Minchin

Minchin and Matilda: two names inextricably linked ever since the Aussie comedian transformed Roald Dahl's classic children's book into the glorious hymn to childhood rebellion and curiosity, Matilda the Musical.

The Royal Shakespeare Company show has wooed critics and audiences on both sides of the Atlantic. But what makes this grown-up kid, born in Perth, nurtured at the Edinburgh fringe and now an adopted Los Angeleno, tick?

"I feel a kindred spirit in Dahl – at least in his love of a rant against anti-intellectualism," said Minchin in a Guardian interview last year. Affirmed atheist, proud ginger and closet romantic, he also added: "I really don't like upsetting people."

With Matilda booking through to 2015 in London and an Australian premiere due in Sydney next year, Minchin is now working on a second musical adaptation, this time of the Harold Ramis film Groundhog Day. But don't let his theatreland endeavours obscure Minchin's other work, with an illustrated poetry book, Storm, set for an autumn release and a role in Australian TV mini-series The Secret River in the works.

He's come a long way from that, ahem, one-star Guardian review. Fresh from headlining the British Summer Time festival at Hyde Park, Tim will be answering your questions in a live webchat on Wednesday 16 July from 1.30pm BST / 8.30am ET. Post them in the comments section below.


Updated

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*